Assume I calculate g as ROE (1–p)/(1–ROE (1–p)) and the Ke from the CAPM. I replace both values in the formula PER = (ROE (1+g) – g)/ROE (Ke-g) but the PER I obtain is totally different from the one I get by dividing the quotation of the share to the earnings per share. Is it possible to interpret that difference as an overvaluation or undervaluation of that share on the market? (Finance Interview Questions With Answers)

Understanding the Discrepancy Between Calculated and Market P/E Ratios

In the realm of financial analysis, the price-to-earnings ratio (P/E ratio) is a widely used metric to assess a company’s valuation relative to its earnings. It represents the market price of a share divided by its earnings per share (EPS). However, discrepancies can arise between the P/E ratio calculated using financial models and the actual market P/E ratio, leading to questions about overvaluation or undervaluation.

The formula you provided, PER = (ROE (1+g) – g)/ROE (Ke-g), is a variation of the Gordon Growth Model, which is a popular valuation model used to estimate the intrinsic value of a stock. This formula incorporates the following key variables:

  • ROE (Return on Equity): A measure of a company’s profitability, representing the net income generated per dollar of shareholder equity.
  • g (Growth Rate): The expected rate of growth in earnings per share.
  • Ke (Cost of Equity): The required rate of return for investors, typically calculated using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM).

The discrepancy between the calculated P/E ratio and the market P/E ratio can be attributed to several factors:

Factors Contributing to the Discrepancy

1. Assumptions and Estimations

The Gordon Growth Model relies on several assumptions, including a constant growth rate and a stable cost of equity. In reality, these variables can fluctuate significantly over time, leading to inaccuracies in the calculated P/E ratio. For example, if the growth rate is overestimated, the calculated P/E ratio will be higher than the actual market P/E ratio.

2. Market Sentiment and Expectations

Market sentiment and investor expectations play a crucial role in determining stock prices. Even if a company’s fundamentals are strong, its stock price can be influenced by factors such as economic conditions, industry trends, and investor confidence. These factors can lead to a divergence between the calculated P/E ratio and the market P/E ratio.

3. Market Inefficiencies

Financial markets are not always perfectly efficient. Information asymmetry, behavioral biases, and other market imperfections can create opportunities for mispricing. As a result, the market P/E ratio may not accurately reflect the intrinsic value of a company.

4. Short-Term Fluctuations

Stock prices can fluctuate significantly in the short term due to various factors, such as news events, earnings announcements, and market volatility. These fluctuations can create temporary discrepancies between the calculated P/E ratio and the market P/E ratio.

Interpreting the Discrepancy

A significant difference between the calculated P/E ratio and the market P/E ratio can be interpreted as an indication of overvaluation or undervaluation. However, it’s important to consider the factors discussed above before drawing any definitive conclusions.

  • Overvaluation: If the calculated P/E ratio is significantly lower than the market P/E ratio, it suggests that the stock may be overvalued. This could indicate that investors are overly optimistic about the company’s future prospects or that the market is experiencing a bubble.
  • Undervaluation: Conversely, if the calculated P/E ratio is significantly higher than the market P/E ratio, it suggests that the stock may be undervalued. This could indicate that investors are overly pessimistic about the company’s future prospects or that the market is overlooking its true value.

Case Study: Tesla

Tesla, a leading electric vehicle manufacturer, has experienced significant fluctuations in its stock price and P/E ratio. In recent years, Tesla’s P/E ratio has been significantly higher than the average P/E ratio for the automotive industry. This has led to debates about whether Tesla is overvalued or whether its high P/E ratio reflects its strong growth potential and innovative technology.

Some analysts argue that Tesla’s high P/E ratio is justified by its rapid growth, expanding market share, and disruptive technology. Others argue that Tesla’s valuation is unsustainable and that its stock price is likely to decline as its growth slows down and competition intensifies.

Conclusion

The discrepancy between the calculated P/E ratio and the market P/E ratio can be a valuable indicator of potential overvaluation or undervaluation. However, it’s crucial to consider the underlying factors contributing to this discrepancy before making any investment decisions. Market sentiment, investor expectations, and market inefficiencies can all play a significant role in determining stock prices. By carefully analyzing these factors and considering the company’s fundamentals, investors can make more informed decisions about whether a stock is truly overvalued or undervalued.

Leave a Reply